Freedom's Phoenix – "Uncovering the Secrets and Exposing the Lies"

REAL TIME SPOT PRICES

Bitcoin Average: $69604.11 Gold: $2233 Change: $38.8 Silver: $24.94 Change: $0.34
 

Freedom's Phoenix
Newspaper

 
 
Contribute BCH to
Freedom's Phoenix



Contribute Funding by
PayPal or Credit Card

 
Sign-up for FREE
Daily Newsletter
Log-In

See Complete Menu

Special Editions
Translate Page
RSS Feeds
 


Declare Your
Independence

with Ernest Hancock

 
Log-In
Front Page
Page Two
 
 

Freedom's Phoenix
Online Magazine

 
Freedom Forum
Letters to the Editor
Report The News
 

Anarchives:

 

 

Search by Keyword

    Contents by Subject
    Radio/TV Shows
    Feature Articles
    Opinion Columns
    News Stories
    Newsletters List
    Reference Links
 
 

www.universityofreason.com/a/29887/KWADzukm
 
Agorist Hosting
 
Agorist Hosting
 
Agorist Hosting

FREEDOM FORUM

 

Sign up to receive the Freedom's Phoenix Headlines by Email.

HELP FUND FREEDOM'S PHOENIX!
Make a one-time or periodic contribution.
Use your credit card or PayPal account.

Join us on our
Social Networks

Share this page with your friends
on your favorite social network:

   
The Open Borders Cart Before the Welfare Horse Opinion  •  Global Edition
Immigration
Necessary Evil
The Open Borders Cart Before the Welfare Horse
04-10-2006
Dave Gallagher
   When local Philadelphians are talking more about the southern border than Terrell Owens being traded to the Dallas Cowboys, it is a hot issue...this issue is the single greatest perceived negative by many...exploring the LP in their search for a new

Comments in Response

Comment by: Ernest Hancock
   Entered on: 2006-04-10 08:49:47

(I was asked by Jim Peron to post his response to Dave**Q**s article)

Dave Gallagher assumes we are putting the immigration cart before the welfare horse. This argument is one that some, especially those who want to cater to the xenophobic Right, use with certain regularity. Th welfare state supposedly distorts the situation so that we can**Q**t allow people to immigrate to the US because..., because... Well actually they don**Q**t spell it out.

There is welfare and there is immigration and we are simply supposed to draw conclusions. But we are not provided with the evidence. At least Mr. Gallagher provided zero evidence in his essay. He merely says: **QQ**The fact remains however that many illegals consume an enormous amount of public resources.**QQ**

I bet that proportionate to their numbers illegals consume less than native born Americans or legal aliens. Frederick Bastiat gave a lesson I thought most libertarians understood. There is the seen and the unseen. Now let us assume Gallagher**Q**s premise that illegals consume **QQ**an enormous amount of public resources**QQ**. That is what is seen or at least what Mr. Gallagher wants to see.

What is unseen is the amount of money they pay toward those programs. A survey from the US Labor Department recently showed that immigrants have a lower rate of unemployment than native born citizens. If they have lower unemployment that means they have higher labor participation rates. That means they disproportionately pay taxes into the system.

Illegals are less likely to collect welfare than native born Americans because they are illegal. Many simply avoid welfare entirely because it can be used to track them down. They are worried about INS brownshirts knocking on their door. On the other hand they find it very difficult to avoid paying taxes. They pay taxes on the food they buy, the gasoline they use, the salaries they earn. But their illegal status makes it harder for them to collect the so-called benefits which they help fund. But Mr. Gallagher only looks at one side of the equation. He prefers to concentrate only on what they collect and pretend that they pay nothing in toward those costs.

Now let us investigate what appears to be his principle. Welfare is bad. Welfare makes Americans worse off. It makes us so much worse off that we ought to restrict the rights of would be immigrants so they can**Q**t add anything to the burden of welfare.

But there is another group that falls into this category which Mr. Gallagher is ignoring. In fact this insidious group of individuals have traits that are not at all good. Every single one of them is an economic burden and remains so for years. Not a one finds a job upon arrival. Many consume welfare benefits, they flood the hospitals and the schools spend billions on them. Everywhere we look they are consuming billions and billions in taxes in one form or another.

Next to the elderly they are probably the second largest burden on our health system. They are a major component of welfare beneficiaries and they consume the lion**Q**s share of our all funding of education. They are babies. And for years after their birth all they do is take, take, take.

Since immigrants are more likely to be employed than native born Americans we can assume that they, unlike babies, pay more in taxes than they consume in benefits. So if the welfare state somehow justifies preventing immigration to the US then the same logic ought to be mean that our anti-immigrant **QQ**libertarians**QQ** should be demanding that we stop women from having more children. Surely if there is a case for restricting the liberty to immigrate, due to the welfare state, there is an even stronger case to restrict the liberty to have children.

Of course there is a simpler solution. Instead of lobbying to stop immigrants why not lobby to welcome them with one proviso: Anyone who immigrates is not allowed to collect welfare benefits for so many years after their arrival.

Instead of blaming immigrants for the welfare mess Mr. Gallagher would better spend his time going after his fellow legal citizens. They are more likely to be unemployed and thus more likely to consume welfare.

I only have one side point to make. Mr. Gallagher expressed an odd sentiment for an alleged anarchist: **QQ**wrap yourself in the American flag and leave the Mexican flag at home.**QQ** I**Q**m not fond of anyone wrapping them self in any flag. It**Q**s so gauche. Now Mr. Gallagher spoke of his Irish heritage. I grew up in Chicago where the Irish ran the city. They had a tendency to march with Irish flags. The shamrock is not an American symbol and you can hardly find an Irish pub without one of them on display. They even dyed the Chicago River green every year.

I find myself rarely offended by someone with a Mexican flag. After all Mexico hasn**Q**t invaded other nations under that flag. It isn**Q**t a Mexican flag flying over off shore concentration camps. It isn**Q**t a Mexican flag flying outside while detainees are being tortured. These days I find the Mexican flag far less offensive but the mere idea of anyone wrapping them self in the American flag ---- well that**Q**s a different matter entirely. My suggestion is don**Q**t fly any flag. March as individuals.

Comment by: Philly Dave
   Entered on: 2006-04-10 01:12:22

Curiously there were several other articles on the front page that implied or stated a connection between illegal immigration and increased welfare / public service consumption.

A short commentary on my part was not intended to be an all inclusive financial analysis of services received by illegal aliens. Nor would it serve any real purpose as I suspect the numbers would be disputed anyway. Rather this was a critique of what I consider a lack of priority recognition by the LP and some libertarians.

Interestingly you state **QQ**I bet that proportionate to their numbers illegals consume less than native born Americans or legal aliens.**QQ** Proportionality could be debated, but is not relevant to the discussion. You admit as much when you offer your own solution.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
**QQ**Of course there is a simpler solution. Instead of lobbying to stop immigrants why not lobby to welcome them with one proviso: Anyone who immigrates is not allowed to collect welfare benefits for so many years after their arrival.**QQ**
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

I am not lobbying to stop immigration rather I am lobbying to address the transfer of wealth from producers to non-producers before re-opening the entire country lock stock and barrel to an impoverished southern neighbor. Nothing in my writing opposes your suggestion. In fact you, by offering such a solution, have put the **QQ**Welfare Horse**QQ** at least side by side with the **QQ**Open Borders Cart**QQ**.

That is the kind of discussion that should be taking place among libertarians.

As for wrapping oneself in a flag, I thought I made it clear that I am not particularly fond of the practice, but if the immigrants making demands of their hosts *must* express a sense of nationalism it seems rather kindergarten that they might opt for the flag of the country they claim to want to seek citizenship. This was offered as simple unsolicited public relations advice.

     

 

 
 
  Magazine / Newspaper
   Magazine Subscription Info
   Online Magazine List
   Newspaper Subscription Info
   Newspaper Issue List
 
RSS Feeds
   Articles RSS Feed
   Opinions RSS Feed
   Media RSS Feed
   Newsletter RSS Feed
   Smartphone Feed
   Podcast Feed
Radio / TV
   Declare Your Independence
      with Ernest Hancock

Anarchives
   Search by Keyword
   Contents Listed by Subject
   Radio / TV Show Archives
   Newsletter Archives
   News Links
   Feature Articles
   Opinion Columns
   Reference Links

 
Letters to the Editor
   List of Letters
   Write a Letter

 
Join Us
   Subscribe to Magazine
   Membership Sign-Up
   Be a Writer
   Be a Reporter
   Link to Us

 
Marketplace
   Buy Stuff – Sell Stuff

   Store on CafePress.com
More News
   Page Two
   Current News
 
Discussions
   Freedom Forum
 
Advertise
   Intro to Advertising with Us
   Magazine Advertising Rates
   Radio Advertising Rates
   Website Advertising Rates
 
Funding Center
   Support or Promote a Project
About Freedom's Phoenix
   About Us
   Contact Us
   Terms of Use
   Privacy Policy
   Writers List

 
Tutorials – Using This Site
   List of Tutorials
 
Media Resources
   News References
   Blog References
   Government References
 
  FreedomsPhoenix.com
The domain and name of this website are servicemarks of Ernest Hancock.
Website is Copyright © 2024 by Ernest Hancock.  All rights reserved worldwide.
4886 W Port Au Prince Ln, Glendale, AZ 85306 USA.
Website Designed by
USA Web
Advertising

Phoenix, Arizona
 
Time to display page: 0.011 Seconds -- Dynamic Page

Page Views:

free web stats

Stats by StatCounter