Our story continues…
According to the popular version, Ben Bernanke, our flawed hero, has averted a Second Great Depression. When the crisis came in ’07-’08, he calmly took out the text he had written himself: “Dummies’ Guide to Avoiding a Japan-style Deflation”…or something like that.
Then, he followed his own theory…coolly…confidently…cutting Fed rates down to nearly zero, pushing Congress to pass a huge ‘stimulus’ bill, and even forcing Bank of America to take over Merrill Lynch. In this last event, he is accused of deliberately hiding Merrill’s enormous losses and then threatening the BofA board with dismissal if they refused.
Because of Bernanke’s swift and assertive action, the nation’s banking system held together during those critical weeks of late 2008. And because of his monetary (and fiscal) policies, all the worlds’ economies are now in some stage of recovery. Stocks are rising. House sales are increasing. All the indicators point to a better world.
In recognition of the fact that he saved the world, Ben Bernanke was given the nation’s highest honor; Obama picked him to continue as head of America’s central bank, the Federal Reserve…even though his predecessor, a Republican, appointed him.
Everyone needs a story. It’s the way we understand things. Data is just data. Numbers are just numbers. Facts are just facts. Without the framework of a good tale to hold them together, they are worthless.
That’s why, here at The Daily Reckoning, we are suspicious of facts, data and numbers. As for the numbers, they are wrong before they get to us…often intentionally. Then, when they are later straightened out, they sometimes tell a completely different story. Even the ‘facts’ often turn out to be not facts at all…but distorted data, information has been twisted to fit into a storyline.
The more precise the data, meanwhile, the more they lie. Give us a CPI rate of 6.24% and we will give you back two numbers that are total fictions…and another one that turns out to be wrong later. As for the GDP growth rate…don’t even bother to give us a number at all. Whatever the digits say, it’s a lie.
This week came news that the GDP is falling at a 1% rate. This number surprised economists. They thought it was falling at a 1.5% rate. This better-than-expected number encouraged investors to buy stocks; the Dow rose 37 points yesterday. Oil and gold remained more or less where they were.
Economists are frequently surprised. In a study of GDP forecasts, a researcher found that economists did nothing more than extrapolate current trends into the future. If the GDP was growing at 2%…they projected that it would grow at 2.3% the following year. Or maybe 1.9%. These projections were mostly correct. Generally, one year is a lot like the year before. But whenever the direction changed dramatically, economists missed it completely. In other words, they’re not really capable of telling us what the economy will do – unless it does nothing different.
We’ve discussed the emptiness of the GDP figures many times. Just because the GDP is growing doesn’t mean people are really any better off. In fact, GDP growth during the Bubble Epoque was really a measure of how fast people were ruining themselves. Seventy percent of the GDP was consumer spending; as consumer spending went up so did debt. The result was a paradox and a shame – at the end of one of the longest periods of uninterrupted GDP growth in history, the typical householder was poorer than he was than when it began.
That’s why we are skeptical of numbers…especially precise numbers. They lie through their decimals.
What matters is the story…and our story now centers on the role of one man: Ben Bernanke. But the story that most people hear…and believe…is false. It is like GDP growth in the Bubble Era…it may sound right on the surface, but the real story is opposite to what is commonly believed.
Bernanke ‘wrote the book’ on avoiding deflation, ’tis true. But he doesn’t really have a clue what he is doing. He didn’t really avoid a Second Great Depression. There isn’t really a genuine recovery underway. And the world is not becoming a better place as a result of Ben Bernanke’s exertions.
Au contraire…he’s making a natural mess into an unnatural one. He’s turning a depression into a Great Depression. He’s making a bad situation worse.
At least, that is OUR plotline. But we’ll let the story tell itself…day by day…and see where it leads us. If we are wrong about the plot…we’ll find out…
The pound is in trouble. Our currency man, Bill Jenkins, sheds some light on the situation:
“Reason #1: Inflation is falling, which generally means no forecast for a rise in rates. No rising rates means no attraction for investors. Inflation has been falling since October ’08: 5.2%, 4.5%, 4.1%, 3.1%, 3.0%, 3.2%, 2.9%, 2.3%, 2.2%, 1.8%.
“Reason #2: U.K. exports have hit the skids for the period going back to November. Check out these numbers year-over-year: November: $36,260 billion; December: $35,190 billion; January: $34,412 billion; February: $33,046 billion, March: $32,765 billion; April: $32,264 billion; May: $32,239 billion; June: $31,888 billion; July: $32,208 billion. In spite of the flattening out over the last couple reporting periods, there is no recovery here.
“Reason #3: Industrial production in the United Kingdom has maintained double-digit losses since January: -12.1%; February: -12.7%; March: -12.6%; April: -12.4%; May: -11.9%; June: -11.1%. Without production, nothing sells. No sales.. no income. No income… no jobs.
“Reason #4: Thus the unemployment rate has been rising every month since January: 6.3%, 6.5%, 6.7%, 7.1%, 7.2%, 7.6% and 7.8%. Unemployment is still on the rise. Nearly one in five households are living on government benefits, with nearly 2 million children living in homes where no adult is working.
“Finally, in the oddity column…
“Reason #5: Business confidence and consumer confidence have been on the rise (although I am not sure why). I have mentioned to you before that sentiment figures are not really fundamental indicators. However, you can view them in a contrarian light when the real numbers are falling and the sentiment numbers are rising. Everybody wants things to be better but, as St. Paul writes, ‘He that deceiveth himself is not wise.’ And when we do ignore the ‘facts,’ they always come back to bite us!
“This is the foundation of a sucker’s rally. People are drawn out of the woods and back into the mainstream, only to be blindsided by another whack from the recession paddle.”
“Forget properties or shares,” writes a dear reader. Here’s how to make real money:
From the Bristol Evening Post:
“Outside Bristol Zoo is the car park, with spaces for 150 cars and 8 coaches. It has been manned 6 days a week for 23 years by the same charming and very polite car park attendant with the ticket machine. The charges are £1. per car and £5. per coach.
“On Monday 1 June, he did not turn up for work. Bristol Zoo management phoned Bristol City Council to ask them to send a replacement parking attendant.
“The Council said, ‘That car park is your responsibility.’ The Zoo said, ‘The attendant was employed by the City Council…wasn’t he?’ The Council said, ‘What attendant?’
“Gone missing from his home is a man who has been taking daily the car park fees amounting to about £400. per day for the last 23 years…!
“Total sum just short £2.9 million.”
What a summer.
Read Between the Decimals was originally published in the Daily Reckoning on August 28, 2009