![]() |
|
FEATURE ARTICLE |
|
|
|
Obama Warns Insurers - El Diablo Remix
Brock Lorber Blog: Bloody Mary Breakfast Date: 06-22-2010 Subject: Economy - Economics USA Two different articles on two different Presidents Sources: CARACAS, June 18 (Reuters) - Mountains of
rotting food found at a government warehouse, soaring prices and
soldiers raiding wholesalers accused of hoarding: Food supply is the
latest battle in President Hugo Chavez's socialist revolution. WASHINGTON, June 21 (New York Times) "
President
Obama, whose vilification of insurers helped push a landmark
health care overhaul through Congress, plans to sternly warn industry
executives at a White House meeting on Tuesday against imposing hefty
rate increases in anticipation of tightening regulation under the new
law, administration officials said Monday. Venezuelan army soldiers swept through the
working class, pro-Chavez neighborhood of Catia in Caracas last week,
seizing 120 tonnes of rice along with coffee and powdered milk that
officials said was to be sold above regulated prices. The White House is concerned that health
insurers will blame the new law for increases in premiums that are
intended to maximize profits rather than covering claims. The
administration is also closely watching investigations by a number of
states into the actuarial soundness of double-digit rate increases. Jose Guzman, an assistant manager at a store
raided in Catia, watched with resignation as government agents pored
over the company's accounts and computers after the food ministry
official and the television cameras left. “Our message to them is to work with this
law, not against it; don’t try and take advantage of it or we will
work with state authorities and gather the authority we have to stop
rate gouging,” David
Axelrod, Mr. Obama’s senior adviser, said in an interview. “Our
concern is that they not try and, under the cover of the act, get in
under the wire here on rate increases.” "We are bringing order to prices,"
Trade Minister Richard Canan told Reuters during the Catia raid.
"There are traders who are taking these products to the black
market ... That is a crime and our government will continue to target
these stores." The law does not grant the federal
government new authority to regulate health care premiums, which
remains the province of state insurance departments. But with
important provisions taking effect this summer and fall, the Obama
administration has repeatedly reminded insurers " and the public "
that it will expose industry pricing to what the health secretary,
Kathleen
Sebelius, has called a “bright spotlight.” Fighting back, Chavez says he is in an
economic war against the "parasitic bourgeoisie" that tries
to convince Venezuelans that socialism does not work by twisting
facts and taking advantage of honest mistakes. "They know where we are headed, we are
going to take from the Venezuela bourgeoisie the hegemony of
dominance in this country," Chavez, who calls himself a Marxist,
said to applause from supporters on his TV show on Sunday. He has also revived threats to take over the
country's largest private food processor, miller and brewer, Polar. The White House meeting coincides with
Monday’s release of a survey by the Kaiser Family Foundation, a
nonprofit health policy research group, that found that premiums for
the policies most recently bought by individuals had increased by an
average of 20 percent. Food prices are up 41 percent in the last 12
months during a deep recession, government figures show, despite the
government's growing network of state-run supermarkets that sell at
discounts of up to 40 percent and are popular with his poor
supporters. “The survey shows that the steep increases
we have been reading about over the last several months are not just
extreme cases,” said Drew Altman, the foundation’s president. Mr. Obama’s message to insurers will serve
to put the industry on notice and position the White House
politically should voters start to link premium increases to the new
law. With the law expected to play a significant role in the midterm
elections, the president has been using his platform to sell the
bill’s most immediate benefits and, by extension, to defend
Democrats in Congress who risked their careers to vote for it. South America's top oil exporter, Venezuela
imports about 70 percent of its food and analysts say the economic
hardships could give the opposition a boost at the ballot box --
although most expect Chavez to retain a reduced parliamentary
majority He will do so again Tuesday; after his
private meeting, Mr. Obama will appear in the East Room, where he
will highlight new regulations to protect consumers from
discriminatory insurance practices, end lifetime limits on coverage
and ban unjustified revocations of coverage. Mr. Axelrod likened them to “essentially a
patients’ bill of rights, the strongest in history.” "They are not going to stop us in the
plan, which is to give the people what is their right," Chavez
said on Friday during the inauguration of a supermarket chain the
government bought this year from French retailer Casino. White House officials said Tuesday’s
attendees will include top executives from 13 leading health
insurers, as well as Karen M. Ignagni, the president of America’s
Health Insurance Plans, the industry trade group. Five state
insurance commissioners also are expected to attend. The insurers have attributed this year’s
increases to skyrocketing medical costs and to the economic downturn,
which has prompted healthier consumers to forgo health
insurance, leaving a sicker and costlier pool to cover. “Our companies are receiving rate increase
requests from hospitals
across the country of 40, 50 and 60 percent,” said Robert
Zirkelbach, a spokesman for the trade group. “That has a direct
impact on the cost of health care coverage.” Critics accuse him of steering the country
toward a communist dictatorship and say he is destroying the private
sector. They point to 80,000 tonnes of rotting food
found in warehouses belonging to the government as evidence the state
is a poor and corrupt administrator. "The
government is pushing this type of establishment toward bankruptcy,"
said Guzman, who linked the raid to the rotten food scandal. "Somehow
they have to replace all the food that was lost, and this is the most
expeditious way." Much of the wasted food, including powdered
milk and meat, was found last month in the buildup to legislative
elections in September. The scandal is humiliating for Chavez, who
accuses wealthy elites of fueling inflation and causing shortages of
products such as meat, sugar and milk by hoarding food. But a report released Monday by Health
Care for America Now, a coalition that supports the new law,
stressed that the growth in premiums in the first eight years of this
decade had far exceeded medical inflation " 97 percent to 39
percent. The new law requires the health secretary to
work with states to establish a process for annual reviews of
“unreasonable increases in premiums.” Administration officials
said Monday that they were still writing regulations to define
“unreasonable increases.” Chavez supporters are grateful for a network
of cheap state-run supermarkets and they say the raids will slow
massive inflation. Mr. Obama’s approach to the health
insurance industry has rarely been subtle, starting with his
campaign, when he spoke of his dying mother’s struggle to persuade
her insurer to cover her cancer
treatments. In March, with his health bill hanging by a
thread in Congress, Mr. Obama ducked into a White House meeting with
insurance executives to deliver a letter from an Ohio cancer survivor
who had dropped her coverage after learning her premiums were rising
40 percent. But for all of Mr. Obama’s browbeating,
the new health care law stopped short of giving the administration
the power to reject or limit rate increases. Instead, it established
the annual reviews, starting next year, and makes available $250
million in grants to states to implement the review process. States that accept the grants must recommend
whether insurers with patterns of excessive pricing should be allowed
to market policies through newly created exchanges, which will help
individuals and businesses shop for coverage starting in 2014.
Insurers also will be required to justify increases deemed
unreasonable on their Web sites. In the closing weeks of the health care
debate, the White House offered a proposal to give the health
secretary authority to deny unreasonable increases. It did not make
it into the final legislation, but Senate Democrats have reintroduced
it as a standalone bill. The president rushed to give public support
to Oil Minister Rafael Ramirez, who as the boss of PDVSA is also
responsible for food unit PDVAL, over the case of the rotting food. Two former PDVAL managers have been jailed
in the scandal, but that has not stifled opposition charges of
government incompetence. The regulatory clout of state insurance
departments varies widely, with some having minimal power to block
rate increases. But in recent months, several states have taken
unusually assertive steps. In California, state regulators announced
that they would order independent reviews of increases being sought
by four large health insurers. That move came after the department
discovered miscalculations in rate requests by Anthem Blue Cross,
prompting the company to withdraw its plan to raise premiums by as
much as 39 percent. In Massachusetts, the administration of Gov.
Deval
Patrick, a Democrat, used long-untapped power to deny 9 of 10
rate increases requested by the state’s insurers, provoking a
lawsuit from the industry. A court in Maine recently upheld a smaller
rate increase for that state’s largest insurer " 10.9 percent
instead of 18.1 percent " that had been ordered by the insurance
superintendent. In New York, Gov. David
A. Paterson, a Democrat, signed legislation this month giving the
state power to block unreasonable rates. And in Pennsylvania, Gov.
Edward
G. Rendell, also a Democrat, announced two weeks ago that his
insurance commissioner, Joel Ario, would investigate large increases
by the state’s biggest insurers. “The plans are cherry-picking the best
risk,” Mr. Ario, who will attend the White House session, said in
an interview. The federal law, which will require that
most Americans obtain insurance, includes a number of provisions
intended to slow the growth of premiums. For instance, insurance
companies soon will have to spend at least 80 percent of revenue from
premiums on claims, as opposed to administration and profit. Insurers have warned since early in the
debate that the overhaul might result in increased premiums for many
consumers. The Congressional Joint
Committee on Taxation and the nonpartisan Congressional
Budget Office found otherwise, projecting that it would have
minimal effect on group premiums, which account for 83 percent of the
market. Their analysis forecast that premiums for individual policies
would rise faster than they would without the new law, but that the
increases would largely be offset by government subsidies. Whatever the law’s ultimate effect, many
of this year’s most egregious rate increases were announced well
before it was clear the bill would pass. "The battle
for food is a matter of national security," said a red-shirted
official from the Food Ministry, resting his arm on a pallet laden
with bags of coffee. It is also the
latest issue to divide the Latin American country where Chavez has
nationalized a wide swathe of the economy, he says to reverse years
of exploitation of the poor. A string of
expropriations and buyouts of companies during the last couple of
years means the government now controls between 20 percent and 30
percent of the distribution of staple foods. |