Article Image Ernest Hancock

Letters to the Editor • WAR: About that War

Our sanctions at work: 168 dead in Iran

Sure, I know that there\'s a big power struggle going on in Iran right now and that the politicos and the ayatollahs are playing tug of war over who will get control of what. But let\'s focus on something else for right now -- that the Iranian people are some of the nicest, kindest, best-educated, intrepid and interesting people in the world and that these people have all suffered greatly since 1953, when Iran became a political football as the local power elite and foreign super-powers all struggled to get a piece of Iran.

And now all this bickering, hatefulness and spy-vs-spy sub-plotting has gone too far once again (as if the Shah\'s torture chambers and the ayatollahs\' crackdowns weren\'t already enough) -- causing 168 people, all innocent men, women and children, to spin downward into a fiery and terrifying death from the air.

According to the Associated Press, "A Russian-made Iranian passenger plane carrying 168 people crashed shortly after takeoff Wednesday, nose-diving into a field northwest of the capital and shattering into flaming pieces." And politicos all over the world are responsible for this disaster. If your country voted to sanction airplane parts to Iran, you personally killed all these people. Every single one.

When are human beings ever finally going to grow up, start to evolve and put an end to all these stupid Stone Age power struggles that cost American taxpayers at least $110 for every man, woman and child on the planet? We need to stop acting like cavemen! What is modern warfare if not just a more glamorous (and expensive) version of what cavemen used to do with clubs and rocks? Peaceful people all over the world -- especially women and taxpayers -- are getting really tired of having to constantly put up with all this "military" crap.

When I was in Iran last fall, I needed to fly from Tehran to Yadz. My experience on that flight was hair-raising. Why? Because of the sanctions. Under the current foreign sanction policies, Iranians can NO LONGER GET PARTS FOR THEIR PLANES. That\'s disgusting. And now 168 innocent people are dead. "Collateral damage". I guess that means that the sanctions are working.

PS: I\'m currently writing a book entitled, "Iran, Iraq and North Korea: From Axis of Evil to Hot New Tourist Destinations". Here\'s the chapter on my flight from Tehran to Yazd:

October 13, 2008: Hot milk topped off with coffee -- what a luxury! Don\'t laugh. It\'s something that I just never had at home. And dates and yogurt for breakfast. This is about the most exotic thing about Tehran. Almost everything else is fairly Westernized. This is a truly Westernized country. I don\'t think that Americans realize that. Iranians are not "camel jockeys" at all.

"One day a Persian died and was sent to Hell because he was from the Axis of Evil. In Hell, he looked around and one section of Hell looked sort of fun. \'This is the Persian Hell,\' he was told. \'Why are you not like the American Hell and get burning tar poured into your mouth with a funnel every day?\' \'Ah because this is the Persian Hell and we are very disorganized -- plus we have sanctions, so one day we don\'t have the tar and the next day we don\'t have the funnel.\'"

We drove along a street that used to be called "Eisenhower Boulevard". Now it is called "Freedom Street".

"After the revolution, the very first company to come to Iran was Coca-Cola," said my guide. "Also Iran is the world\'s second largest exporter of copper." And also the second largest producer of oil.

"What about sanctions?" I asked.

"They are not working as well as expected for two reasons. First, the European community has too many investments here to support most sanctions, and, second, Iran is industrially self-sufficient in a whole bunch of areas. We even make our own cars." If sanctions were ever applied to America, we\'d be screwed -- because we are in no way industrially self-sufficient.

"Our plane to Yazd is going to be delayed," said my guide. "This is due to sanctions. Airplanes and airplane parts are being sanctioned."

"But why?" It\'s not like these planes are being used for military purposes or nothing. Doesn\'t that put civilians in danger?"

"Yes. We have had a crash recently and it\'s hard to make repairs. We are forced to improvise. We rent planes for instance -- from Russia, Turkey and even Bulgaria. Many of our planes are in such poor shape that they aren\'t allowed to land at European airports." Great. That\'s just what I needed to hear right before our flight to Yazd. "But don\'t worry. We are flying on a Dutch plane today."

"But why doesn\'t Iran make its own planes?"

"Specialization. In today\'s world economy, it\'s not possible to make everything." Oh. So the sanctions actually do end up hurting Iran. "However, the EU can trade with Iran for anything up to 20 million dollars, and there is a lively black market." But what black market do you go to if you want to buy airplane parts? And, more important, will they serve lunch on our flight?

Once on the plane, the captain announced, "We can\'t take off just yet because we are missing a...." I couldn\'t hear exactly what it was that we were missing -- but do I really want to know?

There was a famous Iranian actor aboard our plane and he came over to talk with us. "I hear that you are the Iranian Sherlock Holmes," someone said. The actor smiled.

"I am. Only I\'m better." We all laughed.

The city of Yazd appears to be pretty big from the air. Who cares! I just want to see it from the ground!

Jane Stillwater

Berkeley, CA
 

1 Comments in Response to

Comment by Alastair Stell
Entered on:

Wars happen because people enjoy judging others to be inferior to, or different than, themselves. We even judge ourselves in subtle ways which limit all we can do and all we can be. We allow our ego to become a comfortable prison.

And so to this article. We don't know why the aircraft crashed yet. Isn't this a rush to premature judgement? Do we know if Russia has denied parts to Iran? Or was the airline simply too broke to afford them? Or too lax in its maintenance?

On the issue of parts, is the author aware the government fixes ticket prices in Iran? And that consequently most airlines are work on a shoestring budget that would rule out proper maintenance?

Whenever we rush to judgement based on emotion, personal perspective or ignorance, we are truly no different than those who start wars - we merely lack the means or authority to prosecute them ourselves.

As for women in general, I notice that Margaret Thatcher, Golda Meir, Queen Elizabeth 1 et al. had no problem in going to war and deploying overwhelming force. It is a fundamental conceit to hide behind your sex.

The problem lies within all of us. The solution, if indeed there is one, is to set a better example in eveything you think, say and do. It takes discipline, but if enough people choose to do likewise it will become apparent we have a better way to live our lives. Then, and only then, we might start a viral change in human behaviors which would enable us to become responsible creatures of reason and compassion.


JonesPlantation