That is, until Wednesday, when the 81-year retired physical education teacher was hauled to jail for feeding bears one too many times.
"I just think it's so heavy handed. Way overdone. I don't think that there was much thought given to her age, her physical, her mental condition," says John Payne, who is also a neighbor.
But authorities say she had been warned before. Last November, Fish and Wildlife officers had to euthanize a bear she had been feeding. A judge gave her probation, and made it clear: do it again, and go to jail.
"We sympathize with her and her husband. This is a situation that deteriorated through time and it's an unfortunate outcome," says Gary Morse, Florida Fish and Wildlife Commission spokesman.
Apparently, Musselman didn't go without a fight. An arrest report says she struggled and kicked at officers, then threatened to shoot and kill the wildlife officer if she set foot on her property again.
Wildlife officers say bears that are fed are more likely to get aggressive and more likely to be euthanized.