Freedom's Phoenix – "Uncovering the Secrets and Exposing the Lies"
 
Current Bitcoin
Price:
$521.0063

Provided by
BitPay.com
 
Contribute Bitcoin to
Freedom's Phoenix



Scan the QR Code above, or
double-click on the text in the
box, copy it, and paste it into your
Bitcoin payment application.
Contribute Funding by
PayPal or Credit Card

 
Log-In

See Complete Menu

Special Editions
Translate Page
RSS Feeds
 


Declare Your
Independence

with Ernest Hancock

 
Log-In
Front Page
Page Two
 
 

Freedom's Phoenix
Online Magazine

 
Freedom Forum
Letters to the Editor
Report The News
Newsletter Sign-Up
 

Anarchives:

 

 

Search by Keyword

    Contents by Subject
    Radio/TV Shows
    Feature Articles
    Opinion Columns
    News Stories
    Newsletters
 
 


 

 

 
   

FEATURE ARTICLE

Sign up to receive the Freedom's Phoenix Headlines by Email.

HELP FUND FREEDOM'S PHOENIX!
Make a one-time or periodic contribution.
Use your credit card or PayPal account.

Join us on our
Social Networks

Share this page with your friends
on your favorite social network:

     

Border Patrol Agents Illegally Seize & Search Student's Car in Southern Arizona

Border Patrol Agents Illegally Seize & Search Student's Car in Southern Arizona


Written by
Terry Bressi
Website: Checkpoint USA
Blog: Roadblock Revelations
Date: 12-20-2009
Subject: Arizona's Top News

In yet another example of illegal Homeland Security enforcement activity inside the country, 18 year old Iris Cooper is one of the latest victims of Border Patrol aggression against the traveling public.

Last month, Mz. Cooper was on her way to class at the Pima Medical Institute in Tucson, AZ when she realized she had left her school books at home. Northbound on I-19 in Southern Arizona, she turned around to retrieve them only to be stopped, seized, detained and searched by Border Patrol agents shortly after conducting a perfectly legal about-face. In addition to seizing and searching her, the federal agents added insult to injury by handcuffing her and forcing her to wait thirty minutes for the arrival of a K-9 unit that proceeded to search her vehicle upon its arrival absent consent.

The u-turn took place several miles before an internal Border Patrol checkpoint located along I-19. This is undoubtedly one of the reasons why the Border Patrol was in a position to observe the u-turn in the first place (Homeland Security also has cameras located up and down the I-19 corridor). Regardless of the proximity to the checkpoint however (which is more than twenty-five miles North of the border), to conduct a lawful traffic stop, agents need reasonable suspicion to believe the vehicle is carrying individuals illegally inside the country. This is especially true given the existence of several communities in Southern Arizona located between the I-19 checkpoint and the border. This means there is a lot of domestic traffic along the road at any given time engaging in perfectly lawful and domestic activities.

“Assuming that Congress has the power to admit aliens on condition that they submit to reasonable questioning about their right to be in the country, such power cannot diminish the Fourth Amendment rights of citizens who may be mistaken for aliens. The Fourth Amendment therefore forbids stopping persons for questioning about their citizenship on less than a reasonable suspicion that they may be aliens.” - U.S. v Brignoni-Ponce

To conduct a search, as was done in this case, agents need probable cause or consent:

“Because of the important governmental interest in preventing the illegal entry of aliens at the border, the minimal intrusion of a brief stop, and the absence of practical alternatives for policing the border, an officer, whose observations lead him reasonably to suspect that a particular vehicle may contain aliens who are illegally in the country, may stop the car briefly, question the driver and passengers about their citizenship and immigration status, and ask them to explain suspicious circumstances; but any further detention or search must be based on consent or probable cause.” Pp. 878-882. - U.S. v Brignoni-Ponce

Since agents had neither probable cause nor consent in this case, the search of Mz. Cooper and her vehicle were illegal. Additionally, its unlikely the stop itself was legal since conducting a lawful u-turn along a public highway does not constitute reasonable suspicion to believe a vehicle contains individuals illegally inside the country.

While the Border Patrol claims to be conducting internal roving patrols and checkpoints to protect us from criminal aliens and terrorists, who's protecting us from the Border Patrol?

The newspaper article highlighting Mz. Cooper's experience at the hands of overzealous Border Patrol agents appears below:

Border Patrol went too far, woman says

By JB Miller
Published Friday, November 20, 2009 9:34 AM MST

When Patagonia resident Iris Cooper, 18, turned her car around two miles before a Border Patrol checkpoint because she had forgotten her schoolbooks, she knew there was a chance that agents might stop her. What she didn’t foresee was being allegedly forced from her vehicle and handcuffed for a half an hour while agents waited for a K-9 unit and then searched her car without consent.

“I was very polite and explained that I had forgotten my backpack for school,” said Cooper of the incident that occurred just west of Sonoita on the morning of Nov. 4. She was going to class at Pima Medical Institute in Tucson.

Cooper said that before she knew it, an agent had pulled her from the vehicle and handcuffed her. “When I asked the agent why I needed to be in handcuffs he said, ‘It is part of procedure.’”

Cooper said she waited in cuffs for 15 minutes while a K-9 unit was brought to the scene in order to search her vehicle even though she had not given agents permission to do so. “The K-9 unit went through my car, and there was nothing,” she added.

Agent David Jimarez, a spokesperson for the Border Patrol, said agents more than likely thought they had pulled over a smuggler and that Cooper was cuffed for both their safety as well as her safety. He said that often smugglers will try to run away if they think their vehicle is going to be searched. “The handcuffing doesn’t necessarily mean that she is being placed under arrest,” said Jimarez, referring to Cooper.

However, Dan Pochado, legal director for the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Arizona told the Weekly Bulletin/Nogales International that 99.9 percent of the time such an act would indeed be considered an arrest.

“When you are handcuffed that is effectively an arrest because you are unable to leave voluntarily,” Pochado said. “From the information given, it appears that the level of force here would arise to an unreasonable seizure and a violation, therefore, of the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.”

Pochado said that Fourth Amendment rights protect citizens from unreasonable searches and seizures no matter where they are. He said that while it appears the vehicle had enough suspicion to warrant an investigative stop, agents did not have probable cause for an arrest.

“I hope that the agents explained themselves as to why they did what they did,” said Jimarez. He added that an apology is usually in order under such circumstances.

Cooper said agents did not apologize, but did tell her to, “Have a nice day.”

 

Send Letter to Editor
Additional related items you might find interesting:
News Link  •  Arizona's Top News
Arizona veterans claim victory for marijuana research funding effort
04-16-2014  •  azcentral.com 
News Link  •  Arizona's Top News
Sheriff Mack Responds Federal Terrorism at Bundy Ranch
04-11-2014  •  http://www.dailypaul.com, visible51 
Feature Article  •  More about Arizona's Top News
Chief Tranter Endorses Matt Papke for Tempe City Council
Donna Hancock

Comments in Response

Comment by: Lucky Red (#020562)
   Entered on: 2009-12-20 14:16:44

 Probable cause or consent...ha ha...ROFL!  Somebody is still living in a pre-9/11 fantasy world in which things like constitutional/civil rights mean something.  What a hoot!

       
 
  Magazine / Newspaper
   Magazine Subscription Info
   Online Magazine List
   Newspaper Subscription Info
   Newspaper Issue List
 
RSS Feeds
   Articles RSS Feed
   Opinions RSS Feed
   Media RSS Feed
   Newsletter RSS Feed
   Smartphone Feed
   Podcast Feed
Radio / TV
   Decleare Your Independence
      with Ernest Hancock
   Radio / TV Program List

 
Anarchives
   Search by Keyword
   Contents Listed by Subject
   Radio / TV Show Archives
   Newsletter Archives
   News Links
   Feature Articles
   Opinion Columns
   Reference Links

 
Letters to the Editor
   List of Letters
   Write a Letter

 
Join Us
   Subscribe to Magazine
   Membership Sign-Up
   Be a Writer
   Be a Reporter
   Link to Us

 
Marketplace
   Buy Stuff – Sell Stuff

   Store on CafePress.com
More News
   Page Two
   Current News
 
Discussions
   Freedom Forum
 
Advertise
   Intro to Advertising with Us
   Magazine Advertising Rates
   Radio Advertising Rates
   Website Advertising Rates
 
Funding Center
   Support or Promote a Project
About Freedom's Phoenix
   About Us
   Contact Us
   Terms of Use
   Privacy Policy
   Writers List

 
Tutorials – Using This Site
   List of Tutorials
 
Media Resources
   News References
   Blog References
   Government References
 
  FreedomsPhoenix.com
The domain and name of this website are servicemarks of Ernest Hancock.
Website is Copyright © 2014 by Ernest Hancock.  All rights reserved worldwide.
Feature articles, columns, illustrations, and photographs are copyrighted and may not be
reproduced without the expressed permission of the credited writer, artist, or photographer.
No portion of this website, text, images, or source code may be framed on another website,
copied, reproduced, or distributed, by any means, without the written permission of
Ernest Hancock, 4886 W Port Au Prince Ln, Glendale, AZ 85306 USA.
Website Designed by
USA Web
Advertising

Phoenix, Arizona
 
Time to display page: 0.611 Seconds -- Dynamic Page

Page Views:

free web stats

Stats by StatCounter